1 Reply by sumwg2016 (edited by sumwg2016 2025-09-13 07:21:05)

  • Registered: 2025-08-02
  • Posts: 7

Re: Please Help - Top 10 Robots app

Hello Mr. Popov,
hello members,

i invested a lot of time into research and tests all kind of different EA‘s from Top 10 Robots app and EA Studio. I have run a high speed VPS for generating all kind of strategy’s. I appreciate the work and afford from Mr.
Popov who programmed this software, but i have total different results.

I run the EA‘s on Exness Broker Account with Zero Spread account and very low commissions compare to other brokers.

Can somebody help me? Why are in example a yearly based top 10 Robots app EA is in my account performing 90% losing trades and in the statistics of top 10 Robots app is it one of the best EA‘s? Something is wrong. But i do not get it?

Even if i take IC Markets or BlackBull markets account the results total different. Where is my mistake? I loaded all data correctly.

I see a lot of potential in the software but my results total different.

Please help

  • Popov
  • Popov
  • Lead Developer
  • Offline
  • From: Bulgaria
  • Registered: 2006-11-30
  • Posts: 8,156

Re: Please Help - Top 10 Robots app

> Why are in example a yearly based top 10 Robots app EA is in my account performing 90% losing trades and in the statistics of top 10 Robots app is it one of the best EA‘s?

This does not look correct.

Please test several of the robots in your MetaTrader tester. The MetaTrader test result must be close to the ones shown in the Top 10 app.

...

I personally do not like the idea of the Top 10 application. I listed it on my website simply because I worked on it for more than a year.
The problem is that the application lists pre-generated robots sorted by profit. It misleads traders into believing that downloading Expert Advisors from there is sufficient to start making a profit.

The Expert Advisors from the Top 10 Robots app require thorough testing on the specific platform you use.

We spent several days with Petko Alexandrov from EA Trading Academy (https://eatradingacademy.com) discussing the algotrading trading. They trade with EA Studio, Top 10, Prop App robots, and also with other third-party ready robots.

They conduct extensive testing on various accounts and spend a lot of time choosing which strategies to trade.

I basically created the Top 10 App and the prop App (not listed here) for them.

..

I received a screenshot from Marin Stoianov. He passed a halange yesterday with these robots. He will probably make a video of how he chooses which robots to trade.  (Just what I know from him is that it takes freshly generated robots with a good OOS profit)

https://image-holder.forexsb.com/store/porp-account-marin-thumb.png

...

Samuel, a professional taster and a long-time user of EA Studio, recorded two videos for me with reccomendations.
You may find it interesting to see how he evaluates sth robots.

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/v83xgtk8 … b&dl=0

Popov's Website

3 Reply by sumwg2016 (edited by sumwg2016 2025-09-18 14:08:00)

  • Registered: 2025-08-02
  • Posts: 7

Re: Please Help - Top 10 Robots app

Thanks for the fast answer. The "key" in the linked information .txt is to test the robots on much as possible different brokers and much as possible different instruments. But this will take a long time.

How long the servers where are the Generators run, take time to generate 1 good strategy? Is where +- a duration to generate 1 strategy? Is the strategy generator running behind the top 10 robots app?

Edit: I will not do the things above. The time spend will be huge. I thought the calculated top 10 robots app have a robust test before present the robots. So for me its done. Thanks all smile