forex software

Create and Test Forex Strategies

forex software

Skip to forum content

Forex Forum

Forex Software, Forex Strategies, Expert Advisors Generator

You are not logged in. Please login or register.


(Page 13 of 13)

Forex Forum → Expert Advisor Studio → Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Pages Previous 1 11 12 13

You must login or register to post a reply

RSS topic feed

Posts: 301 to 318 of 318

301 (edited by Naya 2022-05-14 13:22:40)

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Dear Popov,

Are there plans to include Martingale in EA studio?
A robust Martingale portfolio Hedging EA would be a great idea.

I hope you could consider it .
Regards

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Dear Popov,

I would like to have a Stop Loss and Take Profit function as a percentage of the price. I find it more flexible than Fix pip. Because some products have very different price ranges at different times.

So I think there are more options to customize Stop Loss and Take Profit than one. This should allow the strategy to be more flexible to be used in real trading.

I hope this idea is helpful and will be considered by the developers to make it happen.

Best regards.

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Dear Mr. Popov,

Could you please add only entry short position in EA studio.
I really hate long position.
Then I'd like to separate for My EA colection for (Long only and Short only) easily.
e.g.When MACD line above 0 I'd like to use Long EA only.
MACD line below 0 I'd like to use short EA only.
Also Would you please add the number of verification bars for EA studio?

Best Regards.

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

lady7jp wrote:

Dear Mr. Popov,

Could you please add only entry short position in EA studio.

Use Long or Short indicator.

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Dear Mr. footon,

Thank you for reply.

Is the meaning of what you said apply MT4 expert special settings after making EA(Long and Short)?
Please see the attached photo.

I'd like to add trade direction short only.
Because If I making EA from EA studio same setting((long and short) and (long only)).
Long only makes a better EA and it is easier to build a portfolio.

ex...EA studio running about 3hours.
Long and short made 100 strategy.
Long only made 300 strategy.

It also makes it easier to manage EA.

Best Regards.

Post's attachments

2022-05-24 4.14.01.jpg 145.06 kb, file has never been downloaded. 

ea_common.png
ea_common.png 24.12 kb, 1 downloads since 2022-05-24 

You don't have the permssions to download the attachments of this post.

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

As I said use Long or Short indicator from Entry Rule list in the Studio, there's no need to request such a thing if it is already available smile

lady7jp wrote:

Dear Mr. footon,

Thank you for reply.

Is the meaning of what you said apply MT4 expert special settings after making EA(Long and Short)?
Please see the attached photo.

I'd like to add trade direction short only.
Because If I making EA from EA studio same setting((long and short) and (long only)).
Long only makes a better EA and it is easier to build a portfolio.

ex...EA studio running about 3hours.
Long and short made 100 strategy.
Long only made 300 strategy.

It also makes it easier to manage EA.

Best Regards.

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Dear Mr. footon,

Thank you for reply.
I really appreciate it!
I didn't know that use Long or Short indicator from Entry Rule list in the Studio.
I want to say again Thank you so much!!

Post's attachments

_2022-05-25 1.30.18.png 205.33 kb, file has never been downloaded. 

You don't have the permssions to download the attachments of this post.

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

ATR based profit and stop loss in EA studio would be awesome :-)

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Hi Popov,
I've intensively use your awesome software for four months now and I have a few suggestions but for studio this time :-)

1. choose data source in multi-market validation (use case : I use premium data to get more history but I would like to check validated strategies on my broker data with this same instrument and only keep those who are also profitable with it)
2. collection bigger than 300 (use case : I like to let calculations for several days and then take time to validate and filter it with different parameters and acceptance criteria, and may be the one that were pruned who have been better than the ones in the collection on specific criteria, or would have been great in a portfolio in combination with other strategies)
3. when you close the browser, all configuration is saved, so each time I start a generation, I close my browser to save the parameters in case of crash. But it would be awesome to have the ability to save the current configuration in a file and be able to load it afterwards. (use case : keep the exact configuration that I used to generate a collection, and be able to copy a configuration from a computer to another one (as I use several virtual machines to bypass the limitation of multi tabs slow calculations))
4. add an option to set a minimum coefficient between SL and TP (exemple TP must be at least 1.5 times bigger than SL)

And as I said in my previous post, thank you very much for your software which is already awesome. I really love to work with it.
Have a great day
David

310

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

>3. ...  But it would be awesome to have the ability to save the current configuration in a file and be able to load it afterwards.

You can "Download" and "Upload" all the settings from the Settings page. Please see the buttons in the toolbar.


> 4. add an option to set a minimum coefficient between SL and TP

We usually make this by setting desired ranges of SL and TP. (My opinion is that using TP in the Generator may increase the curve-fitting)

311

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

The Portfolio Trader is great

One thing that is missing is greater control over the Testing period

We need a date for Start and end date for the testing period

This would be similar to the MQL tester


Maybe its there and I overlooked it but please help me to find it or make it more prominent in both this as well as FSB.

312

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

> We need a date for Start and end date for the testing period

Please see "Data" => "Data Horizon"

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Hey Popov,
In the Generator, Reactor and Validator, it would be great to be able to run a final optimisation and a final normalisation, when the Walk Forward Optimisation has finished, and use a start date (on the existing data set) as the next optimisation period.  This would allow for the final optimisation of parameters in a pre-live scenario.  For example, the last walk forward period might be:
Opt: 25 Apr 2022 - 26 June 2022
Walk Forward: 27 Jun 2022 to 24 Jul 2022

Final Optimisation: 22 May 2022 to 24 Jul 2022
Final Normalisation: 22 May 2022 to 24 Jul 2022

Those final parameters would be the ones to go live with...

Thanks
Tim

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Wish 1:
My first wish is to block the settings of Strategy/Monte Carlo during a running operation, if "Monte Carlo validation" has been activated. This should allow the user to see that a Generator or Reactor is in progress and the user should not get the idea to change the settings during a running operation.

Wish 2:
I would like to see something like "OOS Monitor" tab for Collection menu, which can be found under the Strategy menu.

The goal is to find better criteria for the "Acceptance Criteria" menu to get better strategies later.

After "Filter records" (if it is considered), in the new "OOS Monitor" tab, each criterion should show a minimum value of all collected strategies.

So every user can decide for himself what minimum criterion he can enter in "Acceptance Criteria" menu.

If such a feature already exists somewhere, I would like to know.

315

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

> My first wish is to block the settings of Strategy/Monte Carlo during a running operation,

Reactor / Validator makes own copies of the Monte Carlo settings when you run it. Later changes don't affect operations.

> I would like to see something like "OOS Monitor" tab for Collection menu,

This is an interesting idea. Thank you!

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Wish 3:
This wish has something to do with wish 2.

If I apply the minimum values of "OOS Monitor" for the following criteria, then some bad strategies will be sorted out.

Average HPR % (min)
Balance line stability (min)
Bars in trade % (min)
Max drawdown % (max)
Months on profit % (min)
Profit factor (min)
Return / drawdown (min)
Sharpe ratio (min)
Max stagnation % (max)

If I apply the minimum values of the next criteria, then the criteria have no influence on the filtering.

Average position length (max)
Max consecutive losses (max)
R - squared (min)
System Quality number (min)
Win / loss (min)

The last criteria are of course still advantageous for "Acceptance Criteria", so that even worse strategies are not generated.

I assume that the current filters only apply to the complete backtest.

I did not compare it, because the work would blow up the time, but it would be quite possible that with further filters for "In Sample (trading) part" and "Out of Sample (trading) part" even more worse strategies could be filtered out.

The resulting values would definitely be helpful for the "Acceptance Criteria" menu.

317 (edited by lady7jp 2022-09-02 01:11:11)

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Hi Popov,

My Request:

1.Wish
Correlation Matrix(Portfolio).
It is really helpful chosen portfolio EA.
https://forexsb.com/forum/misc.php?action=pun_attachment&item=4766&download=0

2.Wish
Available Preset Indicators setting.
Trend following and Mean reversal.
I would like to combine Trend following EA and Mean reversal EA.

3.Wish
Sort Collection by New(add),Old(add).

4.Wish
(Entry)Enter at Stop.

Thank you all, I hope what I have requested is possible.

Post's attachments

2022-09-01_07h49_41.png 59.15 kb, file has never been downloaded. 

You don't have the permssions to download the attachments of this post.

318

Re: Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Hi,

I'm running the builder for the last month and half and already found some very good strategies (have the major learning work done with other builders), so far, this one is the best I've tested. Will stick only with him from now on.

These are my 2 cents, but would definitely be awesome to see these features:

1- multiples OOS across the test: it would be great if we could have the opportunity to distribute different OOS, for example randomly X% each year or so.

2- multiple currencies / assets builder. That would save a lot of ressources and time.

3- entry type: having to opportunity to choose between pending orders (stop / limit) and direct entries. This way we can target some specific strategies we are looking for (breakout, mean reversion, etc...).

Thanks again and keep safe guys,

Posts: 301 to 318 of 318

Pages Previous 1 11 12 13

You must login or register to post a reply

Forex Forum → Expert Advisor Studio → Expert Advisor Studio - Wish list

Similar topics in this forum