It can be done separate with an extra HIDDEN EA made by the user for all or some EAs running
This EA can check also statistics of each EA of portfolio or other EA and if no good close specific EA
It can be part of EA portfolio also
Possibly I will try to do it in future myself.

The EA studio EAs can be used with many ways of management.
I think this is the main reason Popov does not want to complicate the things and keeps the code simple.

I just gave some ideas for all of us to talk about.
EA studio can keep i.e. all trades in a file (trading or not) and user use another file to open or close EAs to run even changing a parameters file.

You can consider these 2 options:

1) Use a profit trailing stop: I personally find the profit trailing stop EA, as a dynamic way to handle and close orders.  It's a much more reactive and responsive method than closing with exit rules (unless your exit rules are so perfect and accurate).

For trailing EA, I would recommend either Vanessa Trailing (cost $30 right now, mentioned here https://forexsb.com/forum/post/54380/#p54380 or Trailling OS by Tim (free for the time being, mentioned here https://forexsb.com/forum/post/54290/#p54290

2. Use Fxblue Profit/Loss (P/L) Manager app (free)

User guide for you to read more about it https://www.fxblue.com/appstore/u6/pl-m … guide#toc2

You start P/L Manager by attaching the EA to a chart in MetaTrader. The EA's "Allow live trading" setting must be turned on before starting. The "Allow DLL imports" setting must also be turned on if you want to shut down MT4 when the target is hit.

Set the high and low triggers at which P/L Manager should close orders: the CloseAboveUpperPnL and CloseBelowLowerPnL parameters

There is a saying, "Let Your Profits Run"

Let your profits run is an expression that encourages traders to resist the tendency to sell winning positions too early. The flipside of letting profits run is to cut losses early. The way to make money as a trader, according to many, is to follow both of these pieces of advice.

For example:

1.  I don't want to close all orders when target profit is hit.  Because it's a blanket rule and some EA may still be better off to keep it running.

2. Instead of closing all orders when account's profit target is hit, if I use profit trailing, I can still keep the profitable EA running with appropriate profit trailing and break even setting (such as Vanessa Trailing EA, it has 5 different levels of profit targets and 3 levels of break even targets) so that I can keep the profit running when secure my targeted profit.

3.  And at the same time, I'm not cutting my losses too early (for other losing EA) with a blanket rule of closing all trades.

its easy to make it.

-create a button
-create a function to get all Positions in profit and call the ClosePosition function

;-)

but i prefered to use something like takeprofit basket for all open orders if xxx amount reach close all..or if xx% reach close all

ok so you will get it ;-)

HERE put outside ontick

this

//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|                                                                  |
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
double Open_Orders_Profit()
{
   double openordersprofit = 0;
   RefreshRates();
   int Total=OrdersTotal();
   if(Total>0)
   {
      for(int i=Total-1; i>=0; i--)
      {
         if(OrderSelect(i,SELECT_BY_POS,MODE_TRADES)==TRUE)
         {
            const int magicNumber = OrderMagicNumber();
            if(OrderSymbol()==Symbol() && (1000 * Base_Magic_Number <= magicNumber && magicNumber < (1000 * Base_Magic_Number + 100)))
            {
               openordersprofit +=OrderProfit()+OrderSwap()+OrderCommission();
            }
         }
      }
   }
   return(openordersprofit);
}

That will count all profits of open orders.

Now you have to work with that.

add input variable

input double               TakeProfitAll           = 100;

in Ontick add this.

void OnTick()
  {
    if(Open_Orders_Profit()>=TakeProfitALL)
   {     
      Print("CLOSED ALL OPEN POSITIONS DUE TO TAKEPROFIT ALL REACHED: "+DoubleToString(Open_Orders_Profit(),2)+"| TAKE PROFIT SET: "+DoubleToString(TakeProfitALL,2));
      CloseAllPositions();      
   }

Have a nice weekend.

Update for all Interested.

After 1 Week with this System and 0.01 Lot i have 97 USD Profit.

Let us see what this week make.

Ive just intergrated this code into my portfolios with some great results!

However im wondering 2 things:

1: The takeprofitall value is that in pips?
2: Is it possible to help me reverse this so I can close all when in loss, this way we have Close all in Profit and Close all in Loss?

Roughey,
can you please look in attached Picture? I have a error and no Idea for that. Can you help me?
Thanks, Marcus

Cool, Michael1. Thank you

I must say, when i backtest it is not good. But the Backtest makes all Trades in the same moment open.

I have this now run over 2 weeks live and the trades goes not instantly open, only backtest. in live i have very good results.

Hi rant,

I have tested this and I don’t have very good results at all lol. I think it’s more got to do with the strategies you use it on more than anything.

I do not know if anyone cares. if it does, here is an update of the variant after 6 weeks. Still with 0.01 lot.
The collapse at about 1,741 trades was on the broker, stood still for minutes and the Closebefehl has hit too late and at the worst moment.

I would like to read from others also the experiences. does anyone want to discuss in an extra thread?

In Attachment is the Balancechart after 6 Weeks.

P.S.: I have nothing changed, it is the same Portfolio in EurUsd as before 6 weeks.
No Monte Carlo, No Multi Market No Walk Forward. Nothing. Only few Minutes Search in Generator.

I have no Special Settings use.
Only Tickstory Data for EurUsd M5 from 01.01.2018 till now.
Generator without Special Settings. Only SL maybe use from 10 to 100 and TP maybe use from 10 to 100.
Then run the Generator for 15 Minutes and no check the Backtest. Only put the 100 Strategies in Portfolio.