<![CDATA[Forex Software — Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/topic/3158/multiple-unwanted-adds-to-a-position/ Mon, 23 Apr 2012 20:07:17 +0000 PunBB <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14120/#p14120

2012.04.20 17:08:58,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91998, TakeProfit=0.90587) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:08:58,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

Broker returns error on OrderModify where the error is "no error".
when FST sees that it's order is not executed, it sends the order again.
Read this thread: http://forexsb.com/forum/topic/3173/debug-fst-expert/

Update your expert and try again. Be sure that the expert is really updated. The version number is written in the log file and in the MT4 journals.

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 20:07:17 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14120/#p14120 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14113/#p14113 thanks; didn'r know that's where expert was wriitng   As best I can tell, this is the  log for April 20 15m USDCHY incident I was describing in my post. 

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 17:08:55,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.91013 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 17:08:57,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.91013, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91997, TakeProfit=0.90586, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19080428, LastError=0
2012.04.20 17:08:57,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19080428
2012.04.20 17:08:57,AggregatePosition Ticket=19080428, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.91316, Lots=0.05, Profit=15.14, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91997, TakeProfit=0.90586, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 17:08:57,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19080428
2012.04.20 17:08:57,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19061490, Price=0.91581, StopLoss=0.91998, TakeProfit=0.90587) Response=1 LastError=0
2012.04.20 17:08:57,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91998, TakeProfit=0.90587) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:08:57,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91998, TakeProfit=0.90587) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:08:58,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91998, TakeProfit=0.90587) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:08:58,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91998, TakeProfit=0.90587) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:08:58,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 17:08:59,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.91013 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 17:09:00,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.91013, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91997, TakeProfit=0.90586, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19080429, LastError=0
2012.04.20 17:09:00,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19080429
2012.04.20 17:09:00,AggregatePosition Ticket=19080429, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.91265, Lots=0.06, Profit=16.59, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91997, TakeProfit=0.90586, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 17:09:00,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19080429
2012.04.20 17:09:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19061490, Price=0.91581, StopLoss=0.91970, TakeProfit=0.90559) Response=1 LastError=0
2012.04.20 17:09:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91970, TakeProfit=0.90559) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:09:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91970, TakeProfit=0.90559) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:09:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91970, TakeProfit=0.90559) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:09:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19062547, Price=0.91555, StopLoss=0.91970, TakeProfit=0.90559) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 17:09:00,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

SetBreakEvenStop
2012.04.20 17:11:11,BreakPrice=0.91265
2012.04.20 17:11:12,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19061490, Price=0.91581, StopLoss=0.91265, TakeProfit=0.90559) Response=1 LastError=0

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 22:13:05,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90895 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 22:13:07,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90895, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19081969, LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:13:07,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19081969
2012.04.20 22:13:07,AggregatePosition Ticket=19081969, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90974, Lots=0.03, Profit=1.70, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 22:13:07,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19081969
2012.04.20 22:13:07,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91880, TakeProfit=0.90469) Response=1 LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:13:07,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91880, TakeProfit=0.90469) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:08,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91880, TakeProfit=0.90469) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:08,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91880, TakeProfit=0.90469) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:08,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91880, TakeProfit=0.90469) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:08,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 22:13:17,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90895 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 22:13:17,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90895, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19081970, LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:13:17,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19081970
2012.04.20 22:13:17,AggregatePosition Ticket=19081970, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90954, Lots=0.04, Profit=1.44, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 22:13:17,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19081970
2012.04.20 22:13:18,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:18,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:18,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:18,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:18,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 22:13:32,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90892 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 22:13:32,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90892, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91876, TakeProfit=0.90465, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19081974, LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:13:32,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19081974
2012.04.20 22:13:32,AggregatePosition Ticket=19081974, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90942, Lots=0.05, Profit=1.24, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91876, TakeProfit=0.90465, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 22:13:32,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19081974
2012.04.20 22:13:33,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91877, TakeProfit=0.90466) Response=1 LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:13:33,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91877, TakeProfit=0.90466) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:33,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91877, TakeProfit=0.90466) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:33,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91877, TakeProfit=0.90466) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:33,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080429, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91877, TakeProfit=0.90466) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:33,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 22:13:36,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90897 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 22:13:36,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90897, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91881, TakeProfit=0.90470, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19081975, LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:13:36,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19081975
2012.04.20 22:13:36,AggregatePosition Ticket=19081975, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90934, Lots=0.06, Profit=0.73, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91881, TakeProfit=0.90470, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 22:13:36,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19081975
2012.04.20 22:13:36,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91881, TakeProfit=0.90470) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:36,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91881, TakeProfit=0.90470) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:36,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91881, TakeProfit=0.90470) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:36,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91881, TakeProfit=0.90470) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:13:36,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 22:14:00,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90895 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 22:14:00,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90895, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19081976, LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:14:00,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19081976
2012.04.20 22:14:00,AggregatePosition Ticket=19081976, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90929, Lots=0.07, Profit=0.57, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 22:14:00,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19081976
2012.04.20 22:14:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:14:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:14:00,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:14:01,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 22:14:01,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 22:14:11,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90895 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 22:14:11,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90895, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19081978, LastError=0
2012.04.20 22:14:11,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19081978
2012.04.20 22:14:11,AggregatePosition Ticket=19081978, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90924, Lots=0.08, Profit=0.28, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91879, TakeProfit=0.90468, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 22:14:11,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19081978

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 23:15:48,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90885 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 23:15:48,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90885, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19082265, LastError=0
2012.04.20 23:15:48,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19082265
2012.04.20 23:15:48,AggregatePosition Ticket=19082265, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90920, Lots=0.09, Profit=0.87, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 23:15:48,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19082265
2012.04.20 23:15:48,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 23:15:50,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 23:15:50,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 23:15:50,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458) Response=0 LastError=1
2012.04.20 23:15:50,Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error

FST Request: Add to the current position.
2012.04.20 23:15:55,USDCHF iargs[0]=1 iargs[1]=78 iargs[2]=0 iargs[3]=0 iargs[4]=0 dargs[0]=0.01000 dargs[1]=0.90885 dargs[2]=958.00000 dargs[3]=453.00000 dargs[4]=0.00000 TS0=0;BRE=334
2012.04.20 23:15:55,SendOrder OrderSend(USDCHF, 1, Lots=0.01, Price=0.90885, Slippage=78, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458, "ID = 3", Magic=3), Response=19082266, LastError=0
2012.04.20 23:15:55,OpenNewPosition SendOrder orderResponse=19082266
2012.04.20 23:15:55,AggregatePosition Ticket=19082266, Type=Short, Time=21:37:01, OpenPrice=0.90917, Lots=0.10, Profit=0.84, Commission=0.00, StopLoss=0.91869, TakeProfit=0.90458, "ID = 3"
2012.04.20 23:15:55,AddToCurrentPosition OpenNewPosition orderResponse=19082266
2012.04.20 23:15:56,ModifyPositionByTicket OrderModify(USDCHF, Ticket=19080428, Price=0.91013, StopLoss=0.91867, TakeProfit=0.90456) Response=1 LastError=0

2012.04.23 05:21:00,MT4-FST Expert version 1.10 Closed.

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 16:32:12 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14113/#p14113 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14112/#p14112 Here is how log files look:

http://i.imgur.com/ShDGo.png

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 16:09:38 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14112/#p14112 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14111/#p14111 I believe I did post the MT4 Experts File for one incident  here http://forexsb.com/forum/post/13914/#p13914.  I also posted just above that entry the MT4 Account History,Mt4 Journal and the FST Journal
http://forexsb.com/forum/post/13908/#p13908

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 15:39:22 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14111/#p14111 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14110/#p14110 I want to tell you that the issue happens when Expert opens new order.

Expert doesn't know your strategy. It doesn't know whether you are using Add, or Winner or Nothing.

I think that issue is in the expert.
I updated expert in https://github.com/PopovMP/Forex-Strategy-Trader.
It writes an improved log file, writing log file is allowed by default and expert magic is shown in position comment.

Please find a way to post log files from expert!!!!

If I cannot explain clearly how to find them, ask some friend or expert to help you.

Other option is to use the announced personal assistance via "Windows Remote Assistance" service.

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 15:18:30 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14110/#p14110 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14106/#p14106 Thanks for the quick response.  but for the past several months "Winner" and "Add" have not been working for me correctly.  they used to.  I get  addtional orders with virtually identical time/price vlues, sometime in the same bar, but last week 5 hours [on a 15m chart] after original order.  It happens on both quadcore and dual core PCs for both FXCM and Alpari MT4 accounts.  I have posted the MT4 Account Histories, Experts log, and FST Journal for several of these incidents.    Nothing-Nothing strategies seem to be working OK on both PCs and on both

On 20Apr on a USDCHF-15m Alpari-US Demo chart the MT4-FSTs expert  executed order #19080428 sell at 17:08/.91013 and order #19080429 sell at 17:08/.91013 [Strategy= WinRevLngUpRhook].  For the next 17 15m bars it looks to this novice from examining the MT4Acct Hist, Experts Log and Journal as well as the FST 'Journal", that the expert repeatedly attempted unnsuccessfully to modify order #19080428 Sell.  Finallly on 20Apr, five hours later it successfully placed  orders #19081969 sell @22:13/.90895, #19081970 @22:13/.90895, #19081974 @22:13/.90892, #19081975@ 22:13/.90897, #19081976 @22:14/.90895, and #19081978 @22:14/.90895.  Is this the way the Winner FST sstrategy is supposed to behave??  If not, can anyone out there explain why I sometimes [not always] get this result with Winner FST strategies, on different MT4 platforms, running on different computers, with different operating systems MT4 demo platforms.

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 14:10:14 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14106/#p14106 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14105/#p14105 Add, Winner, Nothing, New position opening or manual opening works in exactly same way. FST call a function named OrderSend to open a new position (or add).

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 13:47:31 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14105/#p14105 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14104/#p14104 well, it's earlly on this week, but I developed a batch of "Nothing,Nothing" FST strategies and so far they have not produced additional unwanted virtually identical time/price orders at some time after the original FST EA order.  "Winner" and "Add" strategies frequently do, lately, with Alpari-US running on quadcore Pc and FXCM noDD MT4 demo running on dualcore PC.  Never had this multiple virtually identical time/price until recently.  I suspect the martingale mod or some other recent mod has screwed up the "Winner" strategy operation. Pity because I liked "Winner" strategies with breakeven settings about 200.

]]> Mon, 23 Apr 2012 13:00:55 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14104/#p14104 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14050/#p14050 On 20Apr on a USDCHF-15m Alpari-US Demo chart the MT4-FSTs expert  executed order #19080428 sell at 17:08/.91013 and order #19080429 sell at 17:08/.91013 [Strategy= WinRevLngUpRhook].  For the next 17 15m bars it looks to this novice from examining the MT4Acct Hist, Experts Log and Journal as well as the FST 'Journal", that the expert repeatedly attempted unnsuccessfully to modify order #19080428 Sell.  Finallly on 20Apr, five hours later it successfully placed  orders #19081969 sell @22:13/.90895, #19081970 @22:13/.90895, #19081974 @22:13/.90892, #19081975@ 22:13/.90897, #19081976 @22:14/.90895, and #19081978 @22:14/.90895.  Is this the way the Winner FST sstrategy is supposed to behave??  If not, can anyone out there explain why I sometimes [not always] get this result with Winner FST strategies, on different MT4 platforms, running on different computers, with different operating systems.

]]> Sat, 21 Apr 2012 07:48:13 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14050/#p14050 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14021/#p14021 Seem to have got, after much deleting and re-installing,  the multiple identical time/price Winner additon problem under control for AlpariUS [Build419] on the dualcore machine, will work next to address any remaining Alpari problems on the quadcore. After that address any remaining  FXCM noDealingDesk MT4 problems on the quadcore, using same FST EAs developed for Alpari using Alpari data. Lessons learned?  If I'm correct in assuming MetaQuotes supplies the basic MT4 platform to both AlpariUS and FXCM [but not to Oanda], whose operations/implementations are then modified, sometimes by a third party [like Boston Technologies], don't try to run them both at the same time on the same multicore PC. Can't believe no other FSB-FST forum member has had this problem.

]]> Fri, 20 Apr 2012 00:56:21 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/14021/#p14021 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13970/#p13970 Ok, i've tried everything I can think of, including deleting and re-installing the MT4 platforms.  Still, on 15m charts, there sometimes is an entry duing one bar, and multiple additonal virtually identical time/kprice entries in that or the next bar.  If one employs only "Nothing" Same firection signal strategies, how long, how many bars does that Nothing insdtruction last?  I can't beleive no other user is having this problem.

]]> Tue, 17 Apr 2012 04:44:45 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13970/#p13970 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13923/#p13923 Have I posted the correct parallel portions of the files? If so,do the three apparently different time bases make any sense to you? Local time on one, Server time on another, GMT on a third??? Have I somehow gotten corrupted FST software?  Perhaps containing Malware? On both computers?  If so, should I clean up my computers, get rid of the corrupted software and start anew? The weird thing is, that these strategies that sometimes [not always] produce multiple additional entries at virtually identical time/prices have been profitable, weekly, especially on the FXCM nodealingdesk MT4 demo. weird.

]]> Fri, 13 Apr 2012 23:02:54 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13923/#p13923 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13914/#p13914 FXCM MT4 "Experts file" 11Apr
2012.04.12 11:11:40    MT4-FST Expert GBPCHF,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 373
2012.04.11 21:30:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2069181 sell 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31310 sl: 1.33265 tp: 1.30293 ok
2012.04.11 21:30:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 18:00:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058410 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31069 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058314 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31061 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058287 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31063 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058247 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31059 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057450 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31090 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:02    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057449 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31095 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31174
2012.04.11 18:00:01    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057448 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31092 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31174
2012.04.11 18:00:01    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057443 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31096 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31178
2012.04.11 17:59:59    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057436 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31084 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31178
2012.04.11 17:59:58    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31178
2012.04.11 17:45:00    MT4-FST Expert GBPCHF,M15: close #2056177 sell 0.01 GBPCHF at 1.45672 sl: 1.46645 at price 1.46056
2012.04.11 09:52:12    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:52:12    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:52:12    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:52:12    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:52:12    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:52:11    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2058410 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31069 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 ok
2012.04.11 09:52:10    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:49:00    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:49:00    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:49:00    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:49:00    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:49:00    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:49:00    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29103 tp: 1.32075 ok
2012.04.11 09:48:59    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2058314 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31061 sl: 1.29105 tp: 1.32077 ok
2012.04.11 09:48:58    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:47:20    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:47:19    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:47:19    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:47:19    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:47:19    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2911, 1.3208) No error.
2012.04.11 09:47:19    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29109 tp: 1.32081 ok
2012.04.11 09:47:18    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2058287 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31063 sl: 1.29105 tp: 1.32077 ok
2012.04.11 09:47:17    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:45:39    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:45:39    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:45:38    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:45:38    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:45:38    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.291, 1.3207) No error.
2012.04.11 09:45:38    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29103 tp: 1.32075 ok
2012.04.11 09:45:37    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2058247 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31059 sl: 1.29105 tp: 1.32077 ok
2012.04.11 09:45:37    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:15:10    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2057450 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31090 sl: 1.29139 tp: 1.32111 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:10    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2057450 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31090 sl: 1.29135 tp: 1.32107 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:10    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:15:09    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:15:09    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:09    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:09    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:09    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:09    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29139 tp: 1.32111 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:08    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2057449 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31095 sl: 1.29141 tp: 1.32113 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:08    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:15:08    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:15:08    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:08    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:08    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:07    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:07    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29142 tp: 1.32114 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:07    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2057448 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31092 sl: 1.29134 tp: 1.32106 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:07    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:15:05    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:15:05    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:05    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:05    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2039768, 1.3071, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2057443 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31096 sl: 1.29139 tp: 1.32111 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 09:15:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error in FST Request OrderSend: No error
2012.04.11 09:15:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Error with OrderModify(2057436, 1.3108, 1.2914, 1.3211) No error.
2012.04.11 09:15:02    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: modify #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29136 tp: 1.32108 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:01    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: open #2057436 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31084 sl: 1.29131 tp: 1.32103 ok
2012.04.11 09:15:01    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 0
2012.04.11 08:43:39    MT4-FST Expert GBPCHF,M15: open #2056177 sell 0.01 GBPCHF at 1.45672 sl: 1.46645 ok
2012.04.11 08:43:38    MT4-FST Expert GBPCHF,M15: Trailing Stop = 0, Mode - bar, Break Even = 373
2012.04.11 04:02:06    MT4-FST Expert USDCHF,M15: Break Even (600 pips) set Stop Loss to 0.9193, Ask = 0.9133
2012.04.11 04:02:06    MT4-FST Expert USDCHF,M15: modify #2039760 sell 0.01 USDCHF at 0.91925 sl: 0.91925 tp: 0.90939 ok

]]> Fri, 13 Apr 2012 17:23:07 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13914/#p13914 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13913/#p13913 Have I posted the correct parallel portions of the files? If so,do the three apparently different time bases make any sense to you? Local time on one, Server time on another, GMT on a third??? Have I somehow gotten corrupted FST software?  Perhaps containing Malware? On both computers?  If so, should I clean up my computers, get rid of the corrupted software and start anew? The weird thing is, that these strategies that sometimes [not always] produce multiple additional entries at virtually identical time/prices have been profitable, weekly, especially on the FXCM nodealingdesk MT4 demo. weird.

]]> Fri, 13 Apr 2012 17:21:16 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13913/#p13913 <![CDATA[Re: Multiple Unwanted Adds to a Position]]> https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13908/#p13908 here are three posts, MT4 "Account History" and MT4 "Experts Log" and FST "Journal"  for EURUSD 15m multiple "winner" additonal winners to an original entry at about 2012 04.11 15:15

first Account History
2039768 2012.04.11 00:32 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.30705 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.11 23:59 1.31178 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.73
  11 ID = 11
2057436 2012.04.11 15:15 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31084 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.11 23:59 1.31178 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.94
  11 ID = 11
2057443 2012.04.11 15:15 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31096 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31178 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.82
  11 ID = 11
2057448 2012.04.11 15:15 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31092 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31174 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.82
  11 ID = 11
2057449 2012.04.11 15:15 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31095 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31174 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.79
  11 ID = 11
2057450 2012.04.11 15:15 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31090 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31171 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.81
  11 ID = 11
2058247 2012.04.11 15:45 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31059 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31171 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.12
  11 ID = 11
2058287 2012.04.11 15:47 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31063 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31171 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.08
  11 ID = 11
2058314 2012.04.11 15:49 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31061 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31171 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.10
  11 ID = 11
2058410 2012.04.11 15:52 buy 0.01 eurusd 1.31069 1.29112 1.32084 2012.04.12 00:00 1.31171 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.02

now the "Experts" log

2012.04.11 18:00:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058410 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31069 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:04    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058314 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31061 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058287 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31063 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2058247 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31059 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:03    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057450 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31090 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31171
2012.04.11 18:00:02    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057449 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31095 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31174
2012.04.11 18:00:01    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057448 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31092 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31174
2012.04.11 18:00:01    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057443 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31096 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31178
2012.04.11 17:59:59    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2057436 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.31084 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31178
2012.04.11 17:59:58    MT4-FST Expert EURUSD,M15: close #2039768 buy 0.01 EURUSD at 1.30705 sl: 1.29112 tp: 1.32084 at price 1.31178

Finally the FST "journal"

2012-04-11 09:15:00,EURUSD M15 An entry order sent: Buy 0.01 lots at 1.31084, Stop Loss 1.29131, Take Profit 1.32103
2012-04-11 09:15:04,FXCM MetaTrader 4 failed to execute order! Returned: No error
2012-04-11 09:15:04,EURUSD M15 An entry order sent: Buy 0.01 lots at 1.31096, Stop Loss 1.29139, Take Profit 1.32111
2012-04-11 09:15:05,FXCM MetaTrader 4 failed to execute order! Returned: No error
2012-04-11 09:15:05,EURUSD M15 Long 0.02 lots at 1.30895, Stop Loss 1.29136, Take Profit 1.32108, Profit 3.51 USD
2012-04-11 09:15:05,EURUSD M15 Long 0.03 lots at 1.30962, Stop Loss 1.29139, Take Profit 1.32111, Profit 3.31 USD
2012-04-11 09:15:06,EURUSD M15 An entry order sent: Buy 0.01 lots at 1.31092, Stop Loss 1.29134, Take Profit 1.32106
2012-04-11 09:15:08,FXCM MetaTrader 4 failed to execute order! Returned: No error
2012-04-11 09:15:08,EURUSD M15 An entry order sent: Buy 0.01 lots at 1.31095, Stop Loss 1.29141, Take Profit 1.32113
2012-04-11 09:15:09,FXCM MetaTrader 4 failed to execute order! Returned: No error
2012-04-11 09:15:09,EURUSD M15 Long 0.04 lots at 1.30994, Stop Loss 1.29142, Take Profit 1.32114, Profit 3.11 USD
2012-04-11 09:15:09,EURUSD M15 An entry order sent: Buy 0.01 lots at 1.31090, Stop Loss 1.29135, Take Profit 1.32107
2012-04-11 09:15:10,EURUSD M15 Long 0.05 lots at 1.31014, Stop Loss 1.29139, Take Profit 1.32111, Profit 2.58 USD
2012-04-11 09:15:10,EURUSD M15 Long 0.06 lots at 1.31027, Stop Loss 1.29139, Take Profit 1.32111, Profit 2.58 USD
2

Think three are about same trades.  Don't understand why 3 different times.

]]> Fri, 13 Apr 2012 09:38:23 +0000 https://forexsb.com/forum/post/13908/#p13908