i have still that problem

What problem?

So to answer my previous question, FST seems to be working as expected and FSB not (as I havent given it the correct 1 & 5 minute data). My logic is right?

I think so. Updating intermediate data may improve the backtest.
What if you try different interpolation method?

Every interpolation method gave same results, however I'm only using 13 weeks of live data so far and adding to it every day from mt4. Going to update the 1 minute and 5 minute data tomorrow.

Thanks for your help.

So to answer my previous question, FST seems to be working as expected and FSB not (as I havent given it the correct 1 & 5 minute data). My logic is right?

I think so. Updating intermediate data may improve the backtest.
What if you try different interpolation method?

Is the bar marked "ambiguous"?
Did you try scanner?

I tried the scanner, no ambiguous bars. I will add though, that my 1minute and 5 minute data are not relevant to my 15minute data. I could update them and rescan to reveal an ambiguous bar.

So to answer my previous question, FST seems to be working as expected and FSB not (as I havent given it the correct 1 & 5 minute data). My logic is right?

FSB probably thinks that the entry signal was before the exit. That's why it cancels the entry after position close. Check Journal by bars carefully for that bar and see if there is a canceled entry signal at the corresponding level. In such case, try using scanner with intrabar data. It will improve the backtest accuracy. Is this bar marked "Ambiguous"?

Yes there was a cancelled order. That was exactly it. So why does FSB differ from FST in this instance?

At least I know that this was just a rare occasion where there was just an overlapping entry signal with an exit signal in one bar.

I'm trying to figure out which one was right. I am trading one lot. Was FSB right to cancel that order. Or was FST right to instigate a new trade after the TP was met from the first trade?

I mean it was a valid signal, but FST shouldnt have traded it, if there was an active trade in progress. But if the entry signal came after the first trade was closed, then FSB should have displayed the trade as normal?

I have zero ambiguous trades for this strategy-data set.

EDIT: Are you saying for my 15minute data to be super accurate I really need to have the corresponding 1minute and 5minutes data for that timeperiod?

A trade initiates in the early hours of this morning and then closes hours later. On the same bar that it closes on, an entry signal is triggered and it enters another trade.

However, when putting the same data into FSB, it shows the first trade but not the second one!

I'm trying to figure out an explanation, it is the same strategy, same data in both situations.

Can FSB be at fault? or does anyone have another theory?

It was like FSB ignored that last signal as there was an exit signal already on that bar? Possible?

Hello,

i wanne use the FST, too and i have noticed that the FSB and FST are different. I read here in the forum that other guys had the same problem, but i dont find a solution.

So my question.
Is it realy, that you have only 1 min TF and only use bar opening ( for open logic)?

I used in my strategy bar closing and a 5Min TF,   Stochastic for MTF

Please take a look to the attached picture.

In FST, there a lot of more Trades as in FSB.
Makes it sense?
Or do it something wrong ?

Thanks for help.

The data looks different to me so I wouldn't expect it to trade the same.

I set all the information correctly, but the results on the FSB are completely different from the results in the FST/MT4.

Does anyone know explain why this happens?

i wanne use the FST, too and i have noticed that the FSB and FST are different. I read here in the forum that other guys had the same problem, but i dont find a solution.

So my question.
Is it realy, that you have only 1 min TF and only use bar opening ( for open logic)?

I used in my strategy bar closing and a 5Min TF,   Stochastic for MTF

Please take a look to the attached picture.

In FST, there a lot of more Trades as in FSB.
Makes it sense?
Or do it something wrong ?

Thanks for help.

http://forexsb.com/forum/post/10758/#p10758

Thanks!